Controversy over PUTTY.ORG website growing fast • The Register

Beware: the people behind PuTTY, the renowned FOSS SSH client for Windows, are not the same people as those behind the PUTTY.ORG website.

An unfolding controversy over the contents of a website that contained links to several different pieces of SSH-related software has escalated. At the time of writing, the owners of the website have replaced this content with anti-vaccination propaganda.

PuTTY is a well-known SSH client by Simon Tatham, “a software engineer and free-software author in Cambridge, UK” as he describes himself. PuTTY has been around for a long time. As far as we can tell, The Register first mentioned it in 2008, when it was already about a decade old. The oldest release described in the change history on its homepage is version “0.45 (released 1999-01-22).”

The issue began because the PuTTY homepage is https://www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/~sgtatham/putty/. The Register‘s own Verity Stob described it as a “charming, ancient website” back in 2013.

The PuTTY software, and Tatham’s homepage, are hosted on Chiark, which is a famous web server in its own right. Let’s put it this way: in 2022 we wrote a news story about the process of upgrading Chiark to Debian 11. Chiark has been running the same installation of Debian since 1993, when there were a total of 693 websites. Sure, its hardware has been upgraded quite a few times, but this is a 32-year-old OS installation. The copy of Debian on “Chiark” has a strong claim to be the oldest running web server.

The thing is that these days, many people tend to expect that well-known software would have a short, simple URL. Such as, in this case, PUTTY.ORG. For instance, Lithuanian hosting company Hostinger links to PUTTY.ORG when discussing SSH, it’s mentioned in answers on StackExchange, and PUTTY.ORG is the first hit on Bing, only then followed by the author’s own site.

However, PUTTY.ORG is nothing to do with PuTTY or Simon Tatham. In fact, it’s owned and run by Bitvise, the vendor of proprietary SSH software for Windows, including a paid server and a free client.

This is not a case of typo squatting. Bitvise owns PUTTY.ORG and has since 2008, when it looked like this – a simple, mostly text page, with pointers to the FOSS PuTTY client, and only after that, to Bitvise’s own freeware SSH client and server. Before Bitvise, PUTTY.ORG belonged to an American web consultancy of the same name.

Using a dot-org domain like this isn’t actively misleading. The company did link to the real PuTTY site, and it did so before its own products. The number of sites linking to PUTTY.ORG show that this causes genuine confusion, but it is cheap advertising.

There was nothing deceptive there. Then blogger PupRed contacted them to ask about it. It seems the company objected to this. Initially, it added a line below its FAQ, which read: “On July 13, 2025, Bitvise was contacted by a political interrogator posing as a journalist.” It went on to reproduce the exchange, which we won’t link to here as it could potentially compromise the individual’s safety.

We contacted Bitvise, and the company’s co-founder, denis bider (who styles his name without capital letters) told us:

The update to which he refers is live at the time of writing. Now PUTTY.ORG no longer links to Bitvise’s own software; instead, it embeds a video by a COVID-denialist and anti-vaccination activist, retired pharmacologist Michael Yeadon.

Youtube Video

To be fair, bider’s own homepage refers to his own musings as “wacky, conspiracy-theorist posts,” such as this one from March claiming “Viruses are made up.” (By way of context, The Reg FOSS desk has a degree in biology and has studied viral reproduction. He can attest that viruses are entirely real, and vaccines help prevent humans and animals from becoming ill due to viral infections. Mr bider is wrong, and so is Dr Yeadon.)

We also asked Simon Tatham, who said:

We hope this article helps clarify the issue. He continued:

®

Bootnotes

In an era when people don’t check who owns what before they link to it, we felt some explanation was necessary.

PuTTY capitalizes TTY because TTY is the Unix abbreviation for a terminal, derived from Teletype. In the 1960s, when the original Unix was written, a physical teletype was the main kind of hardware used to interact with computers. Nowadays tty is a Linux command, but it’s also found in other file names, such as getty.

Historically, putty was the substance glaziers used to secure glass in window frames.

Chiark is a place in the novel The Player of Games by the late great Iain Banks.

In case anyone from Hostinger should read this article and amend their SSH page, this is how it looked at the time of writing.

At the start of 2025, PUTTY.ORG looked like this.

When we started writing this article, there was an additional line accusing PupRed of deception.

At publication time, the page was filled with anti-science rhetoric. The Register has taken the decision not to link to the current live page.

Leave a Comment